This post was prompted by the fact that the last two books I’ve read both coincidentially have the best guy friend winning the girl…something that doesn’t usually happen. (Well, not in the books I read, anyway.)
Now, in most books, the best guy friend is usually the dude who LOSES the girl to the hot, sexy BOYFRIEND. The best guy friend is the one that the girl always complains about her boyfriend and makes him feel so totally miserable because she has no idea that he’s been crushing on her since…what, fifth grade? LOL.
But no, these two guys in these two books won the girl…which I totally did NOT expect because I’d already marked these guys down as losers and was actually rooting for the boyfriend. (Like I did with Jacob in Twilight)
1.) City of Bones:

Now this is Jace.
(Yeah. They put the “boyfriend” on the cover. HAHA without a shirt on! Although, I don’t recall there ever being a scene where he’s shirtless…mmm maybe when he’s, like, injured and recuperating, maybe? I think they just put him half-naked to show the tattoos though., which ARE a significant part of the book…and very eye catching.)
He was totally winning against the guy best friend, Simon Lewis, who was like a total nerd and whose role for most of the book only consisted of doing favors (and creating awkward moments) for the main character, Clary.
Clary was totally all out for Jace…but then….SHE FINDS OUT IN THE LAST PAGES OF THE BOOK THAT JACE IS ACTUALLY HER LONG LOST OLDER BROTHER!!!!!!!
And of course, Simon is very happy about this. Because the top contender has been disqualified in terms of incest.
I dk. I personally thought it was a cruel thing to do to the characters. I mean, it’d be like Bella finding out that Edward is really her great-great grandpa. D: Clary and Jace were like: uh…-blush- -walks away from each other-
But congrats to Simon, all the same.
2.) Memoirs of a Teenage Amnesiac

Will is basically the same as Simon. But before the book actually begins, Will is more ahead of the game than Simon. He’d just kissed Naomi the night before.
Too bad Naomi trips on the top of the stairs, hurts her head, and totally forgets everything about him and later on just thinks he’s nothing but a best friend/co-editor of the school’s yearbook.
Naomi is sort of, kind of confused. (Who can blame her, she is an amnesiac, after all) First, she tries hanging out with her OLD boyfriend, a total, body-obsessed jock named Ace…but finds out that she doesn’t like him anymore and has no idea why she went out with him in the first place.
Enter James. Who actually called 911 after seeing Naomi fall off the stairs and is one of the classic dark, sexy, and brooding types.
How Will wins Naomi in the end: James, who has throughout the story shown some signs of mental instability, goes back to a temporary asylum type facility and later on graduates from high school, “drifting apart” from Naomi. The lonely Naomi has no one to talk to than Will and by means of thoughtful presents (he actually compiled all the videos and photos of the four years she forgot when she fell off the stairs and gave it to her on her birthday…aw…) he wins her back. Yay.
I personally think that being the best guy friend/best girl friend is the hardest place to be when it comes to romantic relationships. I mean, you have to watch the girl/guy you love obsess over this other guy/girl and cry on your shoulder, complain, etc. when things don’t go well. How totally awkward and sucky.
SO, although the two guys’ victories were technically prompted by weird plot devices thrown out by the author, congrats to both characters and for winning the girl after persistently staying by her side.
