Title says all. This circumstance is usually pretty uncommon (THANK GOD), but recently I’ve read two books with this sort of dilemma. 1.) Twilight Series and 2.) Revelations (latest book of the Blue Bloods series…yes, it’s about vampires.)
I mean, I don’t know if it’s because girls can’t resist the sex appeals vampires have or something else because both books have the girl literally loving BOTH her sexy vamp bf and her not-so-sexy but cute human guy. Except, in Revelations, Schuyler (pronounced Skyler) is a half-vampire herself… that has spent most of her life living as a human(not a fledgling like Bella) It’s a nice psychological thing and all, where the girl has to choose between her human self and supernatural vamp self, but COME ON!
Now, there might be a chance that this bugs me because I’ve never been in love and have no idea what it feels like. But is it POSSIBLE to love TWO PEOPLE PASSIONATELY at the same time?!!? Feel free to let me know when you find out.
But still, it is a HORRIBLE plot device because it requires a dues ex machina (in the form of the author manipulating the plot like Stephenie Meyer did with the birth of Renesmee and like Melissa de la Cruz did by having Mimi assault Jack ((the smexy vamp bf)) and force him to realize that she is his soul-mate (complicated bonding stuff. Apparently it’s inescapable like werewolves being imprinted.)
Unlike other love triangles (which are only slightly annoying) the heroine CANNOT solve the problem by herself and is TRULY A TWO-TIMER! (and spends a large part of the book moping about how sucky she is and how she feels sorry for the guys).
Don’t get me wrong, I still loved Revelations and Breaking Dawn and thought both were awesomely epic. Revelations just had bad timing and was published around the same year, not letting me recover from my last fit of annoyance for Bella. D:<
I am going to promise right here and now that I am NEVER going to include one of these in my writing. NEVER.